Sorry to revive an old thread but I am in a similiar quandry to OP. I was considering a gen 1 Alphard, but I would like to get a really good one, and the cost for that seems to be around 10 - 12K. However - to get an early gen 2 Alphard/Vellfire doesnt seem to cost that much more. As the gen 1 ended production 16 years ago, 10 - 12k seems to me to be lot of money for an older model car that is quite expensive to run?
So - I am wondering if I should be investing in a Gen 2 over a Gen 1 ? Is the Gen 2 considered better or worse overall? Are people starting to migrate over to the gen 2 over time? For me the only key downside to a gen 2 seems to be that the seats are not as flexible - specifically that the middle seats are not rotatable. Any other thoughts on the gen 2 vs gen 1, other downsides/upsides to either version?
Just to compare with Nissan - its interesting that the E51 Elgrand is still popular, but the next gen E52 it seems is not as popular, as it is more car based than MPV. But the gen 2 Alphard/Vellfire is still similar to gen 1 and still an MPV.